Is Your Management Company Ready for the Next Storm? A Scorecard for Naples Boards

18 November 2026

Share this article

Ten questions on preparation, response, recovery and insurance

On the Gulf Coast, a management company shows its real quality in the days around a hurricane. Routine months look similar from one firm to the next. A storm does not. How the firm prepared, who was reachable and how quickly recovery started are things a board remembers for years.

The quiet months after hurricane season are the right time to grade that performance, while the details are fresh and before next June. The ten questions below give Naples, Marco Island and Collier County boards a way to do it.

Before the storm

  1. Is there a written storm plan for our community, not a general company handout? It should name the buildings, amenities, equipment and shut-off points that are specific to the property.
  2. Did the board see and approve the plan before the season started?
  3. Are vendors lined up in advance? Ask which contractors have agreed to respond for debris removal, roofing, water extraction and tree work, and whether those agreements are in writing.
  4. Is the property documented? Dated photos and video of roofs, common areas and equipment make insurance claims far easier.
  5. Do owners know what to do? Seasonal residents in particular need clear instructions on shutters, lanais, vehicles and who has access to a unit while they are away.

During and right after

  1. Who is our contact when the office is closed or without power, and how do we reach them?
  2. How quickly was the property inspected once it was safe, and how soon did the board get a written report with photos?
  3. How were owners kept informed, especially those who were out of state?

Recovery and insurance

  1. Who managed the insurance claim day to day, and how was that work billed? Some contracts include claim support in the base fee and others charge by the hour. The board should know which before a claim, not after.
  2. Is the manager preparing the board for the next insurance renewal? That means current property information for the agent, a record of repairs and mitigation work, and enough lead time to review options.

For high-rise and mid-rise buildings

Condominium buildings carry extra items. Ask how elevators, generators, fire systems and garage flood protection are handled before a storm and checked after. Ask who decides when a building is safe to re-enter and how that is communicated. For buildings that are three habitable stories or higher, the association's structural integrity reserve study and inspection records should be part of what the manager keeps current, since insurers and engineers will ask for them after an event.

How to grade the answers

For each question, note whether the answer was a clear yes with evidence, a partial answer or a no. Clear answers to eight or more suggest the firm takes storm work seriously. Vague answers on the vendor, communication or insurance questions are the ones to press on, because those gaps only show when it is too late to close them.

Ask your manager to walk the board through the scorecard at a meeting. The conversation itself is useful. It often turns up something simple, such as an out-of-date owner contact list, that can be fixed in a week.

If your board is comparing firms

Put the same ten questions to every company you interview and ask each for an example from a past storm. Our guide to comparing management proposals shows how to line the answers up beside fees and staffing.

Take it to your next meeting: Download the storm readiness scorecard (PDF).

Frequently asked questions

When should the board review its storm plan?

Once after each season to capture what was learned, and again in spring before the next season begins.

Is storm work included in the management fee?

It depends on the contract. Preparation is often included, while extended recovery and claim work may be billed separately. Check the fee schedule.

Who is responsible for the storm plan, the board or the manager?

The board is responsible for the association. The manager prepares and carries out the plan under the board's direction.

Related reading: Switching property management companies in Naples.

Talk with our Naples team

If your board would like to see how we prepare and report for communities in the Naples area, request a quote.

This article is general information for association boards and is not legal or insurance advice. Consult the association's attorney and insurance agent about your coverage and obligations.

Recent Posts

Mid-rise condominium building with balconies at sunset
18 November 2026
What a Naples condo board takes on when it self-manages: Chapter 718 deadlines, records, financial reports, director education and building duties.
18 November 2026
How Naples HOA and condo boards can compare management proposals side by side: scope, staffing, fees, contract terms and questions to ask.
Wooden letter tiles spelling Q and A on a table
16 November 2026
Answers to common questions from Naples condo and HOA boards about HB 797, Florida's rewritten nonprofit corporation law, effective July 1, 2026.
Empty boardroom table and chairs before a board meeting
16 November 2026
How DBPR's new condo citation and penalty rules work, when a director can be removed for willful and knowing violations, and how directors can protect themselves.
Judge's gavel on a desk beside a person signing legal paperwork
16 November 2026
A 2026 legal update for Naples and Collier County condo and HOA boards: five changes that took effect this year and three rules that stayed the same.
Board members meeting with a community association manager
11 November 2026
A practical guide for Collier County HOA and condo boards on changing management companies, from the contract review to the records handoff.
November 2026 Board Governance Review cover: two neighbors face off over a fence while their dogs gr
30 October 2026
Practical guidance for Florida boards navigating disagreement, difficult conversations, and community conflict, with Chapter 718 and 720 meeting rules.
Business meeting around a conference table, with a presenter speaking at the front and a chart on sc
29 October 2026
The August 2026 Board Governance Review covers Florida condo and HOA membership meetings: notice, quorum, voting, video conference rules and common pitfalls.
Board Governance Review Legislative Supplement, September 2026 cover: DBPR Administrative Updates ov
29 October 2026
The September 2026 Legislative Supplement covers Florida's final DBPR education rules for condo (61B-19.001) and HOA (61B-19.004) board directors.
by Association Management Team • 28 October 2026
Discover how boards can reinforce clear delegation, coordinate with property management, correct misunderstandings, and maintain professional working relationships while keeping decisions aligned with established governance practices.
Show More