How Naples Boards Can Compare Management Proposals Side by Side
Scope, staffing, fees and contract terms, lined up in one table
When a Naples or Collier County board requests management proposals, the responses rarely arrive in the same format. One firm leads with price, another with staffing, a third with technology. Without a common framework, the board ends up comparing presentation style instead of substance.
This guide gives boards a practical way to line proposals up side by side. It works whether the association is a high-rise condominium on the Gulf, a gated HOA, or a master-planned community with sub-associations.
Start with a written scope before you ask for proposals
The cleanest comparisons start before the first proposal arrives. Send every firm the same summary of the community:
- Number of units or parcels, and the type of association (condominium, HOA or master association).
- Amenities, staff and shared structures the association maintains.
- Current budget size and any major projects planned for the next two years.
- How many board meetings are held each year and when.
- Any active issues, such as delinquencies, insurance claims or ongoing litigation.
Firms that work from the same facts produce proposals you can actually compare.
Build a comparison table
Put each proposal into one table with these rows:
- Assigned manager. Who will manage the community, their license, and how many other associations they handle.
- Site presence. Number of scheduled site visits or inspections, and whether any on-site staff are included.
- Meetings. How many board meetings are included, and the charge for additional ones.
- Financial services. Monthly statements, budget preparation, collections, accounts payable, and the annual financial report.
- Base fee. How it is calculated (per unit, flat or tiered) and what it includes.
- Charges outside the base fee. The firm’s full fee schedule: hourly rates for work beyond the scope, storm-response and insurance-claim support, and any setup fee at the start of the contract.
- Technology. Owner portal, online payments, work orders and records access.
- Contract terms. Length, renewal, termination notice and any termination fee.
Leave a cell blank when a proposal doesn't address an item, then ask that firm about it in writing.
Ask what is required by law, and see if the contract reflects it
For condominiums, section 718.3025, Florida Statutes, requires a written management contract to specify the services provided, how often they are performed, the costs the association will reimburse and the minimum number of personnel assigned. It also requires disclosure of any financial or ownership interest a board member or service provider holds in the contracting party. A contract missing these terms is not enforceable as written.
Every management contract with a Florida association must also include, in at least 12-point type, the statement required by section 468.4334 that the manager will abide by all professional standards and record-keeping requirements imposed under part VIII of chapter 468. If a draft contract is missing either piece, ask why before going further.
Questions that separate strong proposals from the rest
- How does the firm handle storm preparation and post-storm recovery for Gulf Coast properties?
- Who covers the community when the assigned manager is out?
- How quickly are owner calls and emails answered, and is that commitment in writing?
- How does the firm prepare the board for budget season and reserve decisions?
- What happens to the association's records, accounts and passwords if the contract ends?
- Can the firm provide references from Collier County associations of similar size and type?
Interview the finalists
Narrow the field to two or three firms and invite them to a board meeting or a workshop. Ask the proposed manager to attend, not only a sales representative. Ask each finalist to walk through a recent situation such as a special assessment, a delinquency or a hurricane response, and listen for how they kept the board informed.
Weigh the fee against the work
A higher fee is not automatically worse value. Look at what stands behind the number: how many associations the proposed manager already handles, whether an assistant or accounting contact is assigned to your community, and how often someone will be on site. A firm that gives each manager a smaller portfolio usually charges more, and the board gets faster answers in return. For coastal and high-rise communities, ask each finalist how storm preparation, post-storm inspections and insurance renewal support are billed, since those are the months when a board leans on its manager most. Then judge each fee against the service level the firm commits to in writing, not against the lowest number on the table.
Check the transition plan
A good proposal explains how the firm will take over from the current manager: collecting records, setting up bank accounts, notifying owners and vendors, and meeting the board in the first weeks. If your board is moving from another firm, our earlier article on switching property management companies in Naples covers the handover in more detail.
Frequently asked questions
How many proposals should a board request?
Three is a common number. It gives the board enough range to compare without making the review unmanageable.
Should the board choose the lowest fee?
Not automatically. Compare the estimated annual cost, including add-on charges, against the scope and staffing each firm commits to in writing.
Does the contract need to list specific services?
For condominiums, yes. Section 718.3025 requires the services, their frequency, reimbursable costs and minimum personnel to be specified. HOA boards should ask for the same detail.
Who should sign the management contract?
The board approves the contract at a properly noticed meeting, and an authorized officer signs it under the association's governing documents.
Related reading: Creating a vendor selection process that protects your community and Naples property management for boards.
Talk with our Naples team
If your board is collecting management proposals, we can walk you through how we would serve your community. Request a quote.
This article is general information for association boards and is not legal advice. Consult the association's attorney before signing a management contract.











